Creator’s Note: If you haven’t been following the discourse brought up by @ellaharrison, @theredheadedwitch, and @polish_folk_witch They are asking for everyone who is doing Witchcraft in the sphere of business and within the environment of social media. You can see their Social Media Witchcraft original post via Instagram here. I plan to answer this here on Patreon – available to everyone. But if you love YouTube, you can check out videos in that space addressing all the questions they brought. One of my favorite teaching Witches, Laura Tempest Zakroff did a response there, too.
Topic I: Impact on Community
What is my reasoning/inspiration behind sharing my practice online?
When I was first leaning into this way of life, of being a Witch, of practicing the Craft, to seek that energetic connection in as many ways as possible in my life, I was aching for teachers. Yet, I was still exploring, as I encourage every neophyte practitioner to do. I read. I went to events where I could find them – often at bookstores or esoteric cafes. I studied all the books I could find on mythology, anthropology, and the mind, as well as spellcraft, astrology, and divination. I joke sometimes that I grew up a “Cunningham Witch” because there was a lot of Scott Cunningham on my witchy bookshelf. Remember all those Buckland books? I found Starhawk’s books, too. She first exposed me to permaculture from a Witch’s perspective which is a huge part of the way I endeavor to live. She showed how community could be built through activism and just showing people they have power.
But individual teachers didn’t come to light until the internet evolved. I often talk about writing to Lois Bourne at her ‘mushroom cottage’ in the UK before the internet was a thing. You know, snail mail. She responded to me in a handwritten letter! She encouraged me to continue to search and explore. I did. I did more learning, contrasting, comparing, and connecting. Then, the internet gave me even more data to download and integrate with what felt authentic for me as a practice, often naturally attracted to things that would have been done/believed by my ancestors. I’m amid my second Saturn return; I think it’s natural to want to leave behind stories and knowledge. I did a formal Crone Crowning back in 2020 and dedicated that ritual to being the mentor and teacher I would have loved to have when I was first walking the path. Social media is one of the tools in this witch’s kit allowing me to approach all of this more efficiently.
What am I looking to achieve by participating? Do I seek to educate, learn, or connect?
Before I began doing more public Witch work, as well as writing, coaching, and teaching, I used to run a writing group. For a decade I was a lead cheerleader for those in my direct community seeking to integrate their love of writing into their lives. I’m doing the same thing with Magic, with The Craft, with being a Witch. I want to cheer people along the path, let them learn from my experience – mistakes and victories – and carve out their way after that. When I led the writing group, there were often lots of opportunities to learn from those seeking my coaching. The connection that results from that sharing of knowledge is powerful and elevates your life. It’s hard not to be called to that. Besides, above, Spirit was making sure I knew the way. Social media allows my community to come from not only directly about me, but virtually, too. Given how I learned to practice the Craft, I’m excited for those seeking that path to have so many options.
How Do I believe Social media, as a whole, has impacted the community?
I remember having this conversation back in early 2021, I remember some polls or something and I answered this question the same then as I do now: It depends. For myself, and I’m only speaking to my experience, it’s allowed me to discover and interact with way more people and organizations, both for learning and teaching and running a small magic-forward business.
But, I see the negative, too. Just like you find in any public gathering, there will be those there just bent on fucking it up for everyone else. There’s the ‘scammers,’ your garden-variety of Grand Rising thieves who prey on folx desperate for help (or to help). There are the trolls bent on lumping my spicy-psy heathen ways as evil villains. Rabid haters in the DMs are no fun and waste precious resources. There are folx out there who ought not to be proffering services. Then some clients you attract via social media seem to think they own every minute of your time and ask you to cast the Runes again (it’s not just Tarot, friends). But I honestly think the good outweighs the bad. Due in part because we’re able to quickly connect with folx and let them know when people are misbehaving, and demanding structures be put in place to help protect the space. And when we find a platform is causing harm, we pull support (bye-bye XTwitter) or make them shift things (IG/YouTube). I’m also seeing a trend in Witch/mystical circles online to instruct, remind, and demonstrate taking responsibility and practicing discernment.
All that negativity, however, will sometimes expose people even more transparently and allow you to curate a more authentic experience between Witch & community. Again, as mentioned above, some folx may wish to rethink ‘witching’ in such public spaces. We have all witnessed the community self-police when practitioners are low-vibing. When our fellow Witches are harmed somehow, we step up and support them. The nature of the apps allows individuals to step back from or lean in towards certain ‘creators’ in an ever-evolving algorithm dance. Connection or disconnection can be done without much effort. It allows you to curate a virtual circle that is a value added to your Craft. But the key to that experience is the individual. So mileage may vary.
How do I think social platforms such as ticktok, instagram, and YouTube have each impacted education/sharing information?
On the surface, my answer above would apply to this – it depends. Information is easier to access, for sure. However, that answer doesn’t begin to explore the quality of education and information shared online. Understanding ways to determine actual content, let alone its quality could be a whole class offering for the world, not just the Esoteric community, but the non-magical world, too. As consumers as well as content creators on these applications, we need to support and consume non-machine-created and high-quality creators to create a standard. This does not mean we dismiss creators who don’t have slick videos, reels, or posts. I move away from doing some of the things I did as a corporate communicator as a public Witch. I want my future students, supporters, and clients to feel like this way of life is approachable, accessible, and meaningful. I stayed far away from the ‘aesthetic’ argument not too long ago online because I’m a firm believer in ‘you do you, Witch.’ This means there are some good people with slick content, too. Time to apply that witchy perceptiveness again. If they look pro AND they’re doing good work? Wow, let me cheerlead that, too. You know I’m going to do a vibe check. I’m going to dial in my intuition and double-check that any given witchy creator passes the ‘spiritual smell’ test.
I also think that every Practitioner working in these spaces needs to still employ individual responsibility and discernment. The content is not the mission. The mission is why you started this. I had my reset away from that back in 2021. It’s easy to want to connect with your students and community so badly that you get sidetracked. But the Universe offers lots of opportunities to rethink our approach and start anew. Have a mission statement and keep that in mind while you’re using the ‘tool’ that is social media. Social media is not your Craft. It’s not your business foundation. Remember your why and don’t let comparison become your guide. Listen to your intuition, your guides, your ancestors. Divine next steps if you get confused. We walk this path our way. But continue learning, exploring, and seeking to be the best version of Witch you can be.
Is consuming witchcraft contingent becoming a substitute for practice?
The answer to this question, for me, is all about balance and harmony. I think there’s an easy trap to just scroll through social media when we prefer to be meditating, reading, writing, exercising – preparing real food, sleeping, and certainly working magic. Life ebbs and flows. Practice in the Craft does as well. Some months we may be magical af. Others, our altar is a season behind. The important thing is that we recognize and get back to what works for us. There’s always the chance content becomes too prioritized. I can only take care of my practice and provide the knowledge of my experience when asked. If you’re walking the path of the Witch, you’re working with energies to be your most authentic self and live your best life. If you’re asking yourself during a full moon if you’ve done what you set out to do under the new moon, and you’re likely answering the above question yourself. As Witches, we’re regularly checking in with ourselves. Did you achieve what you set out to in Winter and now it’s Spring? Where did you have success? Where do you need to focus more of your time, energy, and resources? Opportunities like this abound in our lives. Again, I return to my time as a writing coach, you’re a writer when you write. You’re a Witch when you Witch. If you’re not practicing your Craft, are you a Witch? If all you’re doing is creating content, there’s probably an imbalance and confusion.
Thanks for reading all of this. What do you think? Topic 2 gets into Influencer Authenticity. I’ll be posting that soon. Very curious, again, to know how you all feel.
Do Good & Be Magic,
~Runa